Best Toasters (2026)
A data‑driven ranking of the most popular toasters on Amazon.
This list uses only factual product attributes and verified marketplace demand.
1. BELLA 2‑Slice Slim Toaster
6 shade settings
Reheat & cancel buttons
10" long slot fits sourdough
Anti‑jam + auto shutoff
2. Amazon Basics 2‑Slice Toaster
6 browning settings
Extra‑wide slots
Cancel / Defrost / Bagel modes
Removable crumb tray
3. Elite Gourmet Long Slot 4‑Slice Toaster
Long slot design
6 toast settings
Reheat, defrost, cancel functions
Built‑in warming rack
4. Elite Gourmet Cool Touch Toaster
6 temperature settings
Extra‑wide 1.25" slots
Cool‑touch housing
Cancel function
5. Nostalgia Hot Dog & Bun Toaster
Toasts 2 hot dogs + 2 buns
Retro design
Includes mini tongs
Works with multiple sausage types
6. GE 2‑Slice Stainless Steel Toaster
Extra‑wide slots
7 shade settings
Removable crumb tray
Stainless steel housing
7. BLACK+DECKER 4‑Slice Toaster
Extra‑wide slots
7 shade settings
Frozen + Bagel modes
Extra‑lift lever
8. Mueller UltraToast 4‑Slice Stainless Steel Toaster
Long extra‑wide slots
6 browning levels
LED display
Cancel / Defrost / Reheat functions
8. Mueller UltraToast 4‑Slice Stainless Steel Toaster
Long extra‑wide slots
6 browning levels
LED display
Cancel / Defrost / Reheat functions
9. Hamilton Beach 2‑Slice Toaster
Extra‑wide slots
Bagel setting
Toast Boost feature
Slide‑out crumb tray
10. Amazon Basics 4‑Slice Toaster
4‑slice capacity
Extra‑wide slots
6 browning settings
Dual independent controls